Title: An Unexpected Party
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Sam buys Frodo a gift that is well beyond his means, and is rewarded by a chance to be the master for a day.

Comments: My, but this one's delightful. Turning the master/servant thing on its head is always fun, and this is one of the best, with a deliciously cheeky servant!Frodo, and a nice meddlesome Bilbo.

Title: Under the Ympe Tree
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: R
Summary: Gaffer Gamgee worries about his missing son.

Title: Tea and Lavender
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NV-17
Summary: Sam's secret is revealed.

Comments: My, but this fic has a lot to answer for...

Title: The Making of Samwise
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: A history of Samwise Gamgee's life as he grows into his destiny.

Comments: Possibly the best F/S out there. It's gloriously long and wonderfully true to canon, and the slow progression of Frodo and Sam's relationship is wonderfully satisfying. There are no superlatives in the tongues of Men, Elves or Hobbits for how incredible this fic is.

Title: Magic and Mischief
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Frodo and Sam conduct a private Yuletide celebration right under the noses of friends and kin.

Comments: This fic is delightful, if improbable. But the thrill of will-they-won't-they-get-caught makes it all the hotter :D

Title: A Letter Unwritten
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: PG
Summary: Sam stands watch in the Emyn Muil, thinking.

Title: Hare and Hounds
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Frodo participates in an Overlithe coming of age ritual. Choose-your-own-adventure: multiple links branch to various pairings.

Comments: Gotta love these bizarre Shire rituals! This one is a lot of fun, and with a neat twist - though the choose-your-own-adventure books I read as a kid never ended like this one...

Title: Fos' Almir
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: PG
Summary: Old and burdened by grief and the bitterness of loss, Sam sails for Valinor. Will he make his peace with Frodo-- and himself-- there?

Comments: Another unique Tol Eressea story; in this one, Sam's choices are not done when he decides to sail.

Title: Forelithe 1482
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: PG
Summary: Secrets are confessed on Rose Gamgee's deathbed.

Title: Foolish Games
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Smut and silliness and improbable hobbitpile fooling around.

Comments: Improbable it may be, but it manages to be hot and funny and sweet all at the same time.

Title: Endurance Beyond Hope
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Expectations clash with reality when Sam arrives in Valinor sixty years after Frodo's departure from Middle Earth. WORK IN PROGRESS

Comments: This is a WIP, but don't let that put you off, because our lads get over a pretty major hurdle right before it cuts off, and it's easy enough to read it as an ending. This is, quite simply, the best Tol Eressëa fic out there. Usually, Sam steps off the boat and it's as though they were only parted yesterday, and lovely though that is in its way, this feels more real, more like a story worth telling as opposed to something borne of a need to fill the chasm that the ending of LotR leaves open. I sincerely hope that this is finished one day, but even in its current state it stands among the best that Frodo/Sam has to offer.

[Note: technically, this is not a "first time" fic, but I have labelled it as such because, well, it might as well be]

Title: Coming of Age
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Sam falls victim to a birthday prank.

Comments: AKA, "Oh dear, I appear to have a naked hobbit in my bed. Whatever shall I do?"

Title: Comfort
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: NC-17
Summary: Sam comforts Frodo in Minas Tirith after the quest.

Title: Cloves and Kisses
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: PG
Summary: Sam is trapped by worse than wargs.

Comments: As bizarre-Shire-courting-ritual fics go, this has to be one of the best. Predictable, sure, and with more than a smattering of het, but it's sweet and charming all the same.

Title: Botheration
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: R
Summary: Frodo overhears Sam talking to himself.

Comments: Frodo turns out to be something of a voyeur, and Sam's rather messy...

Title: 25 Stories Bill the Pony Never Wrote About Sam Gamgee
Author: Bill the Pony
Rating: R
Summary: 25 improbable vignettes. Warnings for humor, slash, MPREG, incest, het, character death, whacking great knives, cannibalism, OOC, bestiality, karaoke, and all sorts of improbable mayhem.

Comments: Number 12 is my personal favourite :-p